Supporters of a prominent Passaic County Muslim clergyman
whose deportation case has been sent back to Immigration
Court for a rehearing are planning fund-raisers, rallies and
petitions to help the spiritual leader stay in the United
States.
NICK BRANDRETH/SPECIAL TO THE RECORD
Imam Mohammad Qatanani's immigration case will
be reheard.
On Friday, mosque President Nabil Abbassi informed the
congregation of the Islamic Center of Passaic County that
their imam, Mohammad Qatanani, will have to wage his battle
to stay here once again.
"We need to show support," Abbassi said. "Get your funds
ready, get ready for rallies and petitions. Round 2 is
already in progress."
The request for community support comes on the heels of
the Board of Immigration Appeals' decision to remand
Qatanani's deportation case to Immigration Court in Newark,
the same court in which he was granted permanent U.S.
residency last September. That apparent victory was
short-lived, however, because the Department of Homeland
Security appealed. DHS alleges Qatanani once had ties to
Hamas, considered terrorist by the U.S. It's a charge the
imam has vehemently denied.
Qatanani's supporters say the imam has broadened the
mosque's outreach to the larger community, and that he is a
force for peace and cross-cultural understanding.
"He has earned his wings, has earned the right to stay in
the United States," said Aref Assaf, a spokesman for the
imam.
During his court battle last year, some of North Jersey's
most prominent political and law enforcement leaders spoke
of Qatanani as a man of peace who had helped them forge ties
in the Arab and Muslim communities.
Rabbi David Senter of the Congregation Beth Shalom in
Pompton Lakes visited the mosque Friday to show his support
for Qatanani. Senter says that although he is a staunch
defender of Israel, after sitting at the imam's trial last
year, he heard nothing from DHS' testimony that seemed to
support its allegations.
"My thoughts and prayers are with the entire ICPC
family," he told the congregation.
Immigration officials have declined comment on the
appeals board's opinion.
Qatanani, who came to the United States on a religious
visa, applied for permanent U.S. residency in 1999 after his
visa expired. But immigration officials denied the request,
saying he failed to disclose on his application an arrest
and conviction by Israel when he visited the West Bank in
1993 because of alleged links to Hamas.
Qatanani maintains that he did not disclose it because he
had been led to believe by Israel that it was an
administrative detention, not an arrest. And Qatanani, who
denies ever having had links to Hamas, argues that the
Israelis never told him he'd been convicted.
In its 12-page opinion, the board said it agreed with
some of Immigration Judge Alberto Riefkohl's decisions. It
agreed, for example, with Riefkohl's rejection of the DHS
argument that among the reasons the imam should be denied
permanent U.S. residency is that he worked here without
authorization from immigration authorities after his
previous work permits expired. The board said Riefkohl was
correct in determining that DHS incorrectly left the imam in
limbo through its delay in renewing his employment
authorization, and that Qatanani should not have been
penalized because of the agency's inaction.
But the opinion took issue with some decisions by the
judge that were critical to his ruling granting the imam
permanent U.S. residency. The board, for example, said the
judge should not have dismissed Israeli documents provided
by DHS as unreliable because, among other things, an
immigration court was not the proper venue for "the
evaluation of the legitimacy of [a] foreign court system."
The board also said the imam must prove that he did not
have links to Hamas.